Animation pack evidence appendix: Protofactor Two-Handed Melee Animset
Companion report: technical evaluation
Evidence status: partial — current mechanical, declaration, runtime-group, and remediation evidence completed; engine and human acceptance did not.
Evaluation date: 2026-09-16
Current evaluator: AnimSmith 0.14.0
Report format: 3
The canonical readiness ladder remains authoritative.
Evaluation scope and provenance
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Pack/edition | Authorized local Protofactor constituent; revision unknown |
| Vendor/source | Protofactor product context; local revision not established by the current listing |
| Delivered scope | 123 retained FBX candidates; source bytes unchanged during replay |
| Target use | Broad game-engine technical intake; no target controller supplied |
| Target engines | Unity 6000.5.8f1 bounded source/controller probe; Unreal, Godot, and Bevy not evaluated |
| Target rigs/packs | Delivered rigs; Basic Locomotion compatibility not freshly evaluated |
| Source manifest | external:protofactor-two-handed-melee/source-inventory.json; SHA-256 1fc1189eb8ccb299fe26ff51bce96d932b7b2dab5c71a0c6adab477937ad7bc7 |
| Evaluation manifest | Retained urn:animsmith:skill:animation-pack-evaluation-manifest:1; current memberships treated as hypotheses and remeasured |
| Acquisition/license provenance | Authorized local commercial input; no legal conclusion |
Evidence coverage
| Surface | Offered/delivered | Evaluated | Findings | Not evaluated and why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Animation files | 123 | 123 | 122 animation-bearing | Engine semantics not implied |
| Rigs/export variants | 123 | 123 | 118 individual-motion files share the 58-bone 3da84463466a skeleton; Humanoid@Blocked2HandMelee.fbx and Humanoid@IdleBlock2HandMelee.fbx use the 56-bone 2b6fe49d5ae6 variant | Retarget/reference-pose behavior not run |
| AnimSmith baseline | 123 | 123 | All inspect/measure/two lint commands exit 0; One duration-sanity warning on Humanoid@GetHitLeftHeavy2HandMelee_RM.fbx; six time-monotonic notes. | N/A |
| Declared contracts | 120 | 120 | 13 pass, 107 fail in each format | Declaration intent needs project/vendor authority |
| Offline visual reports | 0 | 0 | 0 | Not run |
| Engine import/playback | 3 named Unity sources | 3 | Fresh Humanoid import and finite standalone sampling passed | Visual/contact, authored-controller, and player-build behavior not evaluated |
| Blend/mask/retarget | Three named source Playables mixers | Three fixed-root schedules | Finite sampled poses for named cross-pack pairs | No full blend tree, mask, separate target-rig retarget, visual or contact acceptance |
Claim legend
observed-file identifies source structure, observed-animsmith identifies current tool output, inferred identifies bounded hypotheses, and not-evaluated marks open gates.
Evaluation manifest and taxonomy
Current evaluation manifest schema: urn:animsmith:skill:animation-pack-evaluation-manifest:1.
Canonical clip-role inventory
| Canonical primary role | Logical motions | Delivered files | Evidence boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
idle-pose | 8 | 8 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
continuous-locomotion | 56 | 56 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
locomotion-transition | 0 | 0 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
airborne | 5 | 5 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
traversal | 0 | 0 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
action-interaction | 34 | 34 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
reaction-death | 17 | 17 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
emote-cinematic | 0 | 0 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
other-unknown | 0 | 0 | observed-file; evaluator classification, not vendor semantics |
| Total | 120 | 120 | Current exact-file catalog |
Runtime-set inventory
The untested acceptance below applies to each complete set. Named Unity source samples and mixers ran for a smaller subset; they do not establish full-set playback or visual quality.
| Runtime set | Type | Members/variants | Grouping evidence | Validation status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
crouch-combat-8-way | directional-blend | 16 exact files; 8 IP, 8 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/16 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
run-combat-8-way | directional-blend | 16 exact files; 8 IP, 8 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/16 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
walk-combat-8-way | directional-blend | 16 exact files; 8 IP, 8 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/16 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
normal-forward-speed | speed-blend | 6 exact files; 3 IP, 3 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/6 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
draw-combat-put-away | transition-chain | 3 exact files; 3 IP, 0 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 2/3 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
dodge-forward-back | other | 4 exact files; 2 IP, 2 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/4 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
parry-3-way | other | 3 exact files; 3 IP, 0 RM | Current exact-file measurements; grouping is an evaluator-defined hypothesis seeded by retained catalog declarations | 0/3 files pass the retained declaration; whole-set engine and visual acceptance not evaluated |
crouch-combat-8-way-in-place | directional-blend | 8 exact IP files | Selectable variant of the measured crouch-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
crouch-combat-8-way-root-motion | directional-blend | 8 exact RM files | Selectable variant of the measured crouch-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
run-combat-8-way-in-place | directional-blend | 8 exact IP files | Selectable variant of the measured run-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
run-combat-8-way-root-motion | directional-blend | 8 exact RM files | Selectable variant of the measured run-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
walk-combat-8-way-in-place | directional-blend | 8 exact IP files | Selectable variant of the measured walk-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
walk-combat-8-way-root-motion | directional-blend | 8 exact RM files | Selectable variant of the measured walk-combat-8-way source family | Retained gait contracts non-clean; contact/engine acceptance open |
The exact runtime members below record source members and fresh timing/motion for the decision-driving gait sets. No unavailable membership authority is inferred from prose or filenames.
Grouped gait measurements (retained)
Current source members and measurements for the selected runtime scenarios. Selection is an evaluator hypothesis; source identity and measured values are retained below.
For these multi-member gait rows, duration and RM speed cells are set minima, not per-clip values. The ranges below retain authored variation; individual speed assignments are not reproduced here.
The original grouped gait rows below mix eight in-place and eight root-motion files. The selectable eight-member variants follow this retained source table.
| Set/profile | Role or coordinate | Exact members | Variant/type | Timing or motion | Runtime contract |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
crouch-combat-8-way | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@CrouchForward2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForward2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwards2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwards2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsRight2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchRight2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardRight2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx | set_type=directional-blend | duration=1.667 s; rm_speed=0.642 m/s | loop_ip=true; loop_rm=true; sync=not-evaluated |
run-combat-8-way | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@RunForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx | set_type=directional-blend | duration=0.533 s; rm_speed=2.202 m/s | loop_ip=true; loop_rm=true; sync=not-evaluated |
walk-combat-8-way | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx | set_type=directional-blend | duration=1.333 s; rm_speed=0.810 m/s | loop_ip=true; loop_rm=true; sync=not-evaluated |
The grouped table gives minimum duration and RM speed. Run durations span 0.533–0.567 s. Measured RM speed spans are crouch-combat-8-way 0.642–0.835 m/s (ratio 0.769); run-combat-8-way 2.202–2.690 m/s (ratio 0.819); walk-combat-8-way 0.810–1.092 m/s (ratio 0.742). Preserve authored variation unless the project declares a normalization policy; diagonals and cardinals require the full blend test. Measured source in-place phase spreads (cycles, eight measured members each) are crouch-combat-8-way 0.5774; run-combat-8-way 0.6024; walk-combat-8-way 0.7112. Phase spread here is the minimum covering arc in cycles: sort phases in [0,1), include the wraparound gap, then subtract the largest gap from 1. It is not max_circular_deviation_from_mean; neither measure alone proves support-foot or visual compatibility. Keep sync=not-evaluated until the selected synchronization and contact policy is tested. The current catalog also measures normal-forward-speed, draw-combat-put-away, dodge-forward-back, and parry-3-way as evaluator-defined hypotheses; they remain candidate groupings.
Exact runtime members
Each row is one selectable eight-member variant. Numeric duration and RM-speed table values are the measured minima, not a uniform value for every member. The retained current clip catalog measures both run-combat-8-way-in-place and run-combat-8-way-root-motion at 0.533–0.567 s across their respective eight files; their combined group has the same duration range. RM-speed ranges remain in the grouped measurement paragraph above. Continuous-loop declarations remain unaccepted.
| Set/profile | Role or coordinate | Exact members | Variant/type | Timing or motion | Runtime contract |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
crouch-combat-8-way-in-place | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@CrouchForward2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsLeft2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwards2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsRight2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchRight2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardRight2HandMelee.fbx | variant=in-place | duration=1.667 s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
crouch-combat-8-way-root-motion | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@CrouchForward2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsLeft2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwards2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@CrouchForwardRight2HandMelee_RM.fbx | variant=root-motion | duration=1.667 s; rm_speed=0.642 m/s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
run-combat-8-way-in-place | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@RunForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | variant=in-place | duration=0.533 s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
run-combat-8-way-root-motion | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@RunForwardCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@RunForwardRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx | variant=root-motion | duration=0.533 s; rm_speed=2.202 m/s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
walk-combat-8-way-in-place | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | variant=in-place | duration=1.333 s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
walk-combat-8-way-root-motion | eight-way directional gait | Humanoid@WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx; Humanoid@WalkForwardRightCombat2HandMelee_RM.fbx | variant=root-motion | duration=1.333 s; rm_speed=0.810 m/s | loop=true; sync=not-evaluated |
Pipeline-stage coverage
| Stage | Coverage state | Evidence / remaining gate |
|---|---|---|
| Acquire | evaluated-clean | Authorized retained source inventory |
| Preserve raw | evaluated-clean | Replay verified source and config hashes unchanged |
| Inspect | evaluated-finding | Exhaustive current inspect/measure/lint; notes and named warnings retained |
| Segment | partially-evaluated | Exact individual files measured; combined take not semantically segmented |
| Root motion | evaluated-finding | IP/RM measurements captured; controller ownership not evaluated |
| Conform | evaluated-finding | Fresh candidates produced but not adopted |
| Validate | evaluated-finding | Baseline and retained declarations complete; many declarations fail |
| Optimize | not-evaluated | Prune candidates are not production-adopted |
| Export | partially-evaluated | Candidate GLBs exist externally; no engine import acceptance |
| Gate/report | partially-evaluated | Mechanical report complete; engine and human gates open |
Readiness evidence by clip set
| Role or runtime set | File-ready / clip-ready | Set-ready / rig-use | Runtime / acceptance boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Individual motions | Current evaluator reads and measures exact files | Declaration-clean subset only | Named Unity source imports/samples ran; visual behavior not evaluated |
| Directional gait hypotheses | Timing, speed, skeleton, and current errors recorded | 0 contract-clean members in each named gait set | Named source samples and mixers only; full blend, phase, controller, and contact gates open |
| Transition/action hypotheses | Exact files measured | One-shot/loop intent requires authority | Named source Playables schedules ran; authored state graph, contact, and artistic gates open |
Validation-profile status
| Validation profile | Selection | Result / next evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Marketplace intake | selected — vendor-intended | Current source inventory and exhaustive mechanical intake complete. |
| Blended locomotion | selected — evaluator-selected-generic-scenario | Named gait hypotheses measured; selected source mixer schedules ran in Unity, while contracts and full blend review remain open. |
| Root-motion controller | selected — observed-pack-capability | RM variants measured; named Unity source root samples ran where applicable, while controller/collision ownership remains untested. |
| State-machine transitions | selected — observed-pack-capability | Transition candidates identified; named source Playables schedules ran, but authored state transitions and interruptions were not tested. |
| Layered upper body/weapons | not-selected | No mask/socket/IK authority or test. |
| Traversal/environment | not-selected | No target scene or traversal contacts. |
| Contact actions/interactions | selected — observed-pack-capability | Combat files present; weapon/body contacts not evaluated. |
| Retargeted/customizable characters | not-selected | No target rig or reference-pose test. |
| Motion matching/search | not-selected | No database construction or query test. |
| Networked movement | not-selected | No networking or reconciliation design. |
| Runtime performance | not-selected | No target build or benchmark. |
Pack inventory and content evidence
The current inventory contains 123 FBXs: 122 animation-bearing files, 120 individual-motion files, and 1 combined take. 118 individual-motion files share the 58-bone 3da84463466a skeleton; Humanoid@Blocked2HandMelee.fbx and Humanoid@IdleBlock2HandMelee.fbx use the 56-bone 2b6fe49d5ae6 variant. Counts describe physical current inputs, not runtime acceptance.
Current in-place gait phase evidence
Phase spread here is the minimum covering arc in cycles: sort phases in [0,1), include the wraparound gap, then subtract the largest gap from 1. It is not max_circular_deviation_from_mean; neither measure alone proves support-foot or visual compatibility. These are observed-animsmith source measurements for the exact hypotheses above; synchronization/contact acceptance remains open.
| Current hypothesis | Exact source member (Take 001) | Measured phase (cycles) |
|---|---|---|
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchForward2HandMelee.fbx | 0.136668 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchForwardLeft2HandMelee.fbx | 0.162019 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchLeft2HandMelee.fbx | 0.213006 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsLeft2HandMelee.fbx | 0.783259 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchBackwards2HandMelee.fbx | 0.857985 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchBackwardsRight2HandMelee.fbx | 0.840786 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchRight2HandMelee.fbx | 0.635619 |
crouch-combat-8-way | Humanoid@CrouchForwardRight2HandMelee.fbx | 0.145788 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.117562 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.100797 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.239777 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.792904 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.688387 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.710328 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.637374 |
run-combat-8-way | Humanoid@RunForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.151982 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.139942 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkForwardLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.150506 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.382751 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkBackwardsLeftCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.304546 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkBackwardsCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.851128 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkBackwardsRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.694238 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.678060 |
walk-combat-8-way | Humanoid@WalkForwardRightCombat2HandMelee.fbx | 0.653921 |
Mechanical baseline
| Finding/check | Affected scope | Potential impact | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current readability | 123/123 inputs | Enables mechanical intake | observed-animsmith; all four commands per input exit 0 |
| Constant tracks | 17010 notes across 122 animation-bearing files | Storage/evaluation noise; not a gameplay defect by itself | observed-animsmith; baseline ledger SHA-256 ddb5a9e2e0cdc97bd4b768fcf8700da32f4a22358babd50a101416a14c9737d5 |
| Retained declarations | 107/120 non-clean | Blocks admission under those exact declarations | observed-animsmith; contract ledger SHA-256 0438c30a7e86b46ca0be07b02baf0e7145a22125fc6f6f8f8eacfef2047a5267 |
| Structural/timing warnings | Named scope above | Requires bounded author/project decision | observed-file and observed-animsmith |
AnimSmith remediation evidence
| Source issue | Operation/declarations | Result | Independent verification | Remaining caveat |
|---|---|---|---|---|
PF2-01 gait continuity | transform --gait-anchor on 24 selected in-place gait files; retained per-file configs | 24 outputs produced; selected inputs have no accumulating root translation/yaw | 24 inspect and measure commands exit 0; output hashes and diffs captured | Post-config lint remains non-clean; no RM trajectory was transformed; visual/contact residual unresolved |
| Constant-track notes | transform --prune-constant-tracks on Humanoid@IdleCombatA2HandMelee.fbx | Output candidate(s) produced | Inspect, measure, diff, fix dry-run, and config lint captured | 25/25 post-transform config lints exit 1. Candidate adoption and engine/visual acceptance remain open |
Fresh remediation ledger SHA-256 0f15f4171bf799b5e4bef91251f94dbfaaed8d6f4341a59b05be52f8e1b61430. Generated motion stays outside Git.
Engine procedures and evidence
| Runtime | Version | Procedure | Observed result | Remaining gate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unity | 6000.5.8f1 | Fresh named Humanoid source import and standalone sampling: IdleCombatA2HandMelee, WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee, WalkForwardCombat2HandMelee_RM; named Playables mixers: basic-idle-to-twohand-idle, sword-shield-idle-to-twohand-idle, basic-walk-ip-to-twohand-walk-ip. See collection source/controller probe. | Bounded source/controller feasibility for listed sources only; the collection’s 26/26 is a shared aggregate, not this pack’s result | Rendered motion, contact, deformation, full blend, retargeting, authored AnimatorController, player build and performance remain untested |
| Unreal Engine | not evaluated | No current procedure executed | not-evaluated | Import, retarget, root, blend, and visual review |
| Godot | not evaluated | No current procedure executed | not-evaluated | Convert/import, graph, root, contact, and visual review |
| Bevy | not evaluated | No current procedure executed | not-evaluated | Convert/load, graph, root, performance, and visual review |
Rig, masking, and compatibility evidence
| Pack/rig/set pair | Skeleton/retarget | Scale/axes | Root policy | Timing/blend | Overall evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Two-Handed Melee internal gait sets | Current signatures measured; no retarget | No engine scale/axis test | IP/RM files measured; owner not selected | Current duration/speed/phase recorded; full blend absent | Mechanical only |
| Two Handed Melee plus Basic Locomotion | Named Humanoid sources imported on shared SK_Protof-Actor | Unity import scale/axis accepted for named sources only | Gameplay-owned root fixed for IP/idle; animation-owned root finite for tested RM where applicable | Named Playables transitions finite; visual blend not inspected | Bounded source/controller feasibility, not compatibility acceptance |
Limitations and unknowns
- Retained configs are replay controls, not proof that every attack, reaction, parry, or emote should loop.
- Current grouping hypotheses were remeasured from exact files, but vendor/project semantics and the unavailable richer historical membership authority were not reconstructed.
- Generated candidates remain external and unadopted; command success does not lower residual severity.
- Unity evidence is limited to named source import, finite headless poses, explicit root ownership, and named Playables mixers; no rendered visual, contact, retarget, mask, authored-controller, player-build, performance, or artistic acceptance was performed.
Changes between AnimSmith versions
AnimSmith 0.14.0 — current official binary revalidated source hashes, all baseline and declaration commands, named runtime hypotheses, and every retained remediation recipe. AnimSmith 0.10.0 — retained ledgers supplied immutable source/config controls; historical results are superseded for current conclusions.
Reproduction
Official evaluator preflight: release archive, archive SHA-256 4ecf79436f9123c779edb004050da3010b44a2b392e3031facb227d7734fc33e; exact member animsmith-v0.14.0-x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/animsmith, binary SHA-256 c2b9649bc74f8a7e5b5d7361a6feaa93941b2327cd7eee82235024bd4f61e366; tag v0.14.0, peeled commit e8321ad40be5ef6f162b31f085819c039175c3c9; working-tree state: N/A (official archive). Compiled features: fbx, report. Version and required command help plus representative FBX admission passed before evaluation. Preflight: external:animsmith-0.14.0-report-refresh/preflight.json, SHA-256 7034b5043de54e7b30064230db18605d1f96d0ea1477f7b8c56ce817cc73521a.
Official archive https://github.com/mmannerm/animsmith/releases/download/v0.14.0/animsmith-v0.14.0-x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu.tar.gz; archive SHA-256 4ecf79436f9123c779edb004050da3010b44a2b392e3031facb227d7734fc33e; member animsmith-v0.14.0-x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/animsmith; binary SHA-256 c2b9649bc74f8a7e5b5d7361a6feaa93941b2327cd7eee82235024bd4f61e366; tag v0.14.0; commit e8321ad40be5ef6f162b31f085819c039175c3c9; working tree N/A; features fbx/report.
Preflight verified version/help for required commands and representative GLB/FBX admission before replay; scrubbed locator external:0.14.0-report-refresh/preflight.json, SHA-256 7034b5043de54e7b30064230db18605d1f96d0ea1477f7b8c56ce817cc73521a. The read-only helper replayed the retained exact inspect, measure, and two lint invocations with four workers, recorded argv/exit/stdout/stderr and source/config hashes, and did not mutate inputs. Baseline, contract, and remediation ledger digests are ddb5a9e2e0cdc97bd4b768fcf8700da32f4a22358babd50a101416a14c9737d5, 0438c30a7e86b46ca0be07b02baf0e7145a22125fc6f6f8f8eacfef2047a5267, and 0f15f4171bf799b5e4bef91251f94dbfaaed8d6f4341a59b05be52f8e1b61430. Licensed paths, sources, and derivative outputs are excluded from Git and this report.
Fresh Unity evidence: editor 6000.5.8f1, Unity.exe SHA-256 cdc0eeca135394cde79a632aa998aca14b521b58afe8c2750b009aff608be906; probe SHA-256 28cd00897dfd739e2a7bcfa193adab03de3591a1009802946305127b67d1bfb6; result schema animsmith-unity-crosspack-probe-v1, result SHA-256 f067bca91f182b65fab408a1c97b297377a8f361b03d59e809e236aba666652c; log SHA-256 0429bcb9cc7a7492c6637eb799566463ba915243d0a110b4d76cbe75590c8819; 26/26 aggregate required checks passed with 53 nonempty Humanoid bones per sample. This report uses only the named applicable subset above.
Sources
- Protofactor product context and End User License Agreement — context only; local revision remains unknown.